Prevent Plant Cover Crop Options
It appears as if there will be a record number of acres across multiple states this year that will not get planted this spring and will be eligible for the “Prevent Plant” program. (More information on Prevent Plant dates and details can be found at the end of this article.) While not getting a cash crop planted is a negative event, there can be some positives that come out of it. Many of us have been stuck in a corn/soybean rotation (or lack of rotation) for many years and if you have to take “Prevent Plant”, this may be a onetime opportunity for you to break out of this and add diversity to your system.
Ours soils were historically developed from diverse plant and biology growth but much of this has been lost over the years and we struggle finding ways to bring diversity back to the farm. A diverse multi species cover crop mix planted into your prevent plant acres can greatly stimulate soil life and soil biology, while suppressing weeds, interrupting disease cycles and even produce and cycle nutrients for next year’s crops. For growers in livestock regions, you can also provide valuable livestock forage (be sure and follow the Prevent Plant rules on when you can graze)
With all of this happening across a record number of states, we get asked a lot: “What should I plant on prevent plant acres?” Obviously, the correct answer to that is another question: “What do you want to accomplish?” Followed quickly with, “When are you planting this mix?” and “What are your climate and soil limitations?” and most importantly perhaps, “What kind of budget are you allowing for this project?”
In this document we (the Green Cover Seed Team) will address each of these questions individually and try to help you formulate a plan. We encourage you to read through this and then contact one of the sales team here at Green Cover Seed to customize and finalize your mix.
NOTE: We encourage you to do this sooner rather than later as we anticipate supplies on some seeds to get pretty tight as we move into the summer – (this is not a sales tactic but rather the state of where the seed market is at right now.)
Question #1. What do you want to accomplish? What is your goal? We have listed several potential goals here, with a list of species that may be useful for accomplishing that goal. NOTE: Multiple goals can be accomplished at the same time with a diverse cover crop mix….
Suppress weeds: the best way to suppress weeds is with a highly competitive crop that can form a canopy quickly and shade weeds out. Summer annual crops that can form tight, dense canopies and will often outgrow many weeds include sorghum-sudan, forage sorghums, pearl millet, okra, sunflowers, buckwheat, and cowpeas. A mixture of cover crops tends to be more competitive than a monoculture. For example, sunn hemp, although it grows rapidly and gets tall, does not form a dense canopy by itself. Cowpeas can form a dense canopy but do not get tall by themselves. But a combination of sunn hemp and cowpeas allows the viny cowpeas to use the sunn hemp as a trellis, and the cowpeas fill in the gaps between the sunn hemp plants to form a very effective weed suppressing canopy. It may also be helpful to have a mix that can tolerate a herbicide if it comes to that; in that case, you need tolerance to a herbicide that is effective against your target weed. For example, if your target weed is Palmer amaranth, you may want to planta crop that is tolerant to atrazine or metolachlor used pre-emergence, or 2,4-D postemergence, assuming your weed population is not already resistant to those herbicides. If your target weed is Johnsongrass, grassy sandbur or some other grass, you may want a mix of legumes and broadleaves that allow the spraying of clethodim over the top. If you are waiting to plant until late July or early August, then a combination of both summer annual plants and cool-season plants can be used. Brassicas like turnips, radishes, mustard and collards are effective at suppressing weeds, and cereal grains like oats and spring barley can suppress winter annual weeds like henbit and marestail from establishing this fall.
If your goal is to reduce weed issues in next year’s crop, then that changes things as well. Cereal rye planted in the late summer or early fall as part of a mix is one of the best weed suppressing crops if the next crop will be a legume crop like soybeans, as it aggressively ties up nitrogen which leaves none for weeds to use. Soybeans don’t mind, they just fix their own nitrogen. If the next crop is a nitrogen demanding crop like corn, a winter legume like hairy vetch can be used to both produce nitrogen and suppress weeds. Although vetch makes nitrogen, when it is terminated the nitrogen is in the form of protein and must be decayed before it is available to either crop or weeds. You can place a little nitrogen in the furrow where the crop can reach it and the weeds can’t to keep the crop well-nourished until the vetch begins to decay. Both rye and vetch can form a thick mulch that can help suppress small seeded weeds like Palmer amaranth from being able to get to sunlight after germination before they run out of energy. Both rye and vetch contain chemical compounds that stunt weed growth.
Fix nitrogen: nitrogen fixation is best accomplished with a mix dominated by legumes. The best summer annual nitrogen fixer is sunn hemp, followed by cowpeas, forage soybeans, mung beans, and guar. Again, mixtures are capable of fixing more nitrogen than monocultures in many cases, we recommend mixes containing sunn hemp and cowpea combination for summer nitrogen production as it will produce more nitrogen than a monoculture of either species alone. If you are planting later, as in August, then both cool-season and warm-season legumes are viable. Cool-season legumes include ones that will winterkill in most areas (spring peas, chickling vetch, spring lentils, faba beans, woollypod vetch, common vetch) and ones that will potentially overwinter in the north (balansa clover, hairy vetch, winter lentils) and in the south (crimson clover, arrowleaf clover, woolypod vetch, winter peas). An additional possibility for added nitrogen fixation, particularly if you are using a mixture with non-legume components such as sorghum-sudan grass, is to inoculate with our Bi-Azo inoculant, which is capable of fixing a small amount of nitrogen in the rhizosphere of non-leguminous crops.
Build soil organic matter: as we learn more about how soil organic matter is formed, we are realizing the most important contributor to soil organic matter is the root exudates a plant produces, not the aboveground plant growth. Therefore, the best bet is to produce more days of more exudates, of a diversity of species and plant families, along with as much aboveground biomass as possible. Diversity of plant families makes a more nutritious diet for the microbes that build organic matter, as some species have root exudates high in sugar, others high in protein, others high in lipids, others high in minerals; when combined, it makes a more balanced diet than a monoculture. In general, since the production of root exudates depend on the level of photosynthesis, the more biomass a plant produces, the higher the root exudates. Probably the best single plant for producing organic matter is sorghum-sudangrass, as it produces copious amounts of both root exudates and aboveground biomass. Sunn hemp is probably the best legume. Sunflowers are one of the better non-leguminous forbs. Mixtures with these plants are better than a monoculture of the best single one. Rye, triticale, black oats, and annual ryegrass are some of the better cool-season plants. Another key to building soil organic matter is to have as many days of photosynthesis as possible; thus, even though sorghum-sudangrass is great, it will be done at first frost. If you really want to build organic matter, plant a sorghum-sudan dominated mixture as early as possible, then mow or roll it down in late August and drill a cool-season blend with a high percentage of rye or triticale with annual ryegrass in it, without terminating the summer annuals. This will provide a relay of high root exudate production clear through next spring. Anther consideration; if you really, really, really want to build organic matter, then inoculate your first planting with mycorrhizal fungi. The glomalin produced by the mycorrhizal hyphae is the most persistent form of organic matter known and does wonders for the soil.
Provide grazing after Nov 1: since the prevent plant program allows grazing after November 1, you may want to plant a mixture that has high grazing value at that time. As far as summer annuals go, the best plant for stockpiled winter grazing is probably a sorghum that does not head out. Grain production can be a liability, in that if grazing is not regulated with daily moves of portable fencing, the animals can be subject to acidosis from excess grain consumption. If rationed out with portable fencing on a daily move schedule, a little grain can be desirable. Non-heading sorghums can be one of three types: 1) a photoperiod sensitive that will not initiate a head until after daylength drops below 12 hours and 20 minutes in September, such as our Sweet Forever, or 2) a male sterile product, such as our 400 BMR, with no other pollen producing sorghums in the mix or 3) a long maturity product, especially if planting after July 1 north of I-40 or so, such as our Super Sugar DM (conventional) or Silo-pro (BMR). Another summer annual grass that retains good grazing quality into fall is browntop millet. Summer annual legumes that tend to hold their seeds in the pod after frost to act as a protein supplement include mung beans and guar; sunflower also tends to hold onto its high protein, high oil seeds well into the fall. Stockpiled forage sorghum, especially a BMR, has fair grazing quality in winter, but is best suited for a maintenance diet for brood cows rather than growing animals with high expectations of gain. One other option might be to swath the crop (check to see if this is allowed) and leaves the swath in the field for post frost grazing; in this case, just about any sorghum variety will work well. Swathing also allows the drilling of cool-season species after swathing. A final option: spraying a sorghum crop with 2,4-D close to seedhead emergence can sterilize the flowers so no grain is produced. This might be an option is nonheading sorghum varieties are in short supply, and swathing is not allowed. If planting in August, then very few sorghum varieties will produce grain, but can still provide considerable dry matter before frost, but should be blended with cool-season plants for better grazing quality. Most cool-season, August-planted cover crops provide excellent November grazing. The highest yields of fall grazing will come from cool-season spring cereals (spring oats, black oats, spring barley, and spring triticale) and spring pulses (chickling vetch, spring forage peas, spring lentils) along with brassicas such as collards, turnips, rapeseed, and radishes. Cereals and legumes that overwinter provide less fall grazing but can provide spring grazing and/or spring cover and weed suppression, examples include rye, triticale, winter barley, annual ryegrass for grasses, and crimson clover, hairy vetch, and balansa clover for legumes.
If you just want to cover the ground as cheaply as possible and prevent erosion, then let us know, and we can design a mix for that purpose as well. We have some items that are very inexpensive on a per acre basis, such as sunflowers, rapeseed, a blend of conventional forage sorghums, and our remix biological primer. We also have an occasional “fire sale” on items that may be in danger of losing their germ and we want to get them in the ground before they do so. If your goal is “cheap”, just let us know. These items can also provide grazing as well as many of these other goals we have listed, but likely not as well as a mix designed expressly for that purpose.
Note on Chemicals If chemicals were pre-applied to a field that is going into prevent plant, there’s no sense in starting the conversation until you understand the potential chemical effect. NOTE: WE ARE NOT CHEMICAL EXPERTS! Please always consult with your chemical dealers or experts on this topic. Look at the label and other resources. Three of our favorite sources are:
With the excessive rainfall many chemicals break down much faster than the label says and might still work for cover crops but may have grazing restrictions on them yet. This will obviously vary greatly depending on specific soil types, chemicals, location, etc.
If you have concerns about herbicides, contact us before making the investment in a cover crop and we will send you a herbicide testing seed packet. These packets contain multiple plant groups and we encourage you to plant them on the edge of a field and observe closely to give insights on what might work in your field.
We know that this is a lot of information to digest and absorb so please feel free to reach out to any of the Green Cover team to have some personal help walking through this process.
Keith Berns firstname.lastname@example.org
Dale Strickler email@example.com
Colten Catterton firstname.lastname@example.org
Brett Peshek email@example.com
Jakin Berns firstname.lastname@example.org
Noah Young email@example.com
Scott Ravenkamp firstname.lastname@example.org
Zach Louk email@example.com
Davis Behle firstname.lastname@example.org
NOTE: Thank you to Dale Strickler and Colten Catterton for writing the majority of the content above!
Here are a few other resources that you might find helpful in the process (click on the links as needed)
The following information on Prevent Plant was published on Farm Journal’s Agweb.com and was written by Sara Schafer, Top Producer editor and features Gulke Group senior market analysist and crop insurance expert, Jamie Wasemiller. The full article can be found and read here: https://www.agweb.com/
As we near the middle of May, many farmers are running out of time to get their crops in by the crop insurance final planting date. Are you weighing the options of switching up crops or maybe just not planting a field at all? And, do that fast. Depending on the area, final planting dates have already passed or are May 25, May 31 or June 5 for corn. For soybeans, the dates are June 10, June 15, June 20, June 25 or June 30, depending on your location. With spring insurance prices of $4.00 for corn and $9.54 for beans, Wasemiller says, along with the bearish nature of futures prices moving forward, the indemnities provided by prevent plant could be close to or even higher than profits from producing a crop on those acres. “I do think prevent plant is a viable option this year,” he says. For farmers with unplanted acres, covered by insurance, Wasemiller provides four options. For these examples, assume the farmer is planting corn, has an 80% crop insurance coverage level and an APH (actual production history) yield of 180 bu./acre.
Option 1: Submit a prevented planting claim.
With a spring insurance price of $4.00, that gives you a default insurance guarantee of $576 per acre. ($4.00 x 180 x 80% = $576). If you multiple $576 by 55% to calculate your prevent plant indemnity, it comes out to $317. This may not be ideal, but a farmer should be able to make that work on a portion of their acres, Wasemiller says. No other crops can be planted on these acres other than approved cover crops in order for the producer to receive the full 55% prevented planting guarantee. And, in this instance, prevented planting acres will not affect your APH.
Option 2: Do not submit a prevented planting claim and plant a second insurable crop before the late planting period.
If a second crop is planted before the final plant date, coverage for the second crop will replace the coverage for the first. “Essentially those corn acres are now going to soybeans and it is kind of like corn never existed,” Wasemiller says. Therefore, no preventedplanting payment will be issued for the first crop.
Option 3: Submit a prevented planting claim and plant a second insurance crop after the late-planting period.
If the second crop is insured and is planted after the late planting period, a payment of 35% of the prevented planting payment will apply to the corn acres, Wasemiller says. Also, only 35% of the original premium for the policy on those acres will be charged. “Keep in mind that depending on when you switch from corn to insured soybeans, you may also run into late planting period rules for the soybeans if they are planted after their final planting date,” he says. In this case the prevented planted acres will receive a yield equal to 60% of the approved yield, which will now be part of the 10-year history.
Option 4: Plant the original crop during the late planting period.
Of course, Wasemiller says, farmers also have the option of planting their crops after the final planting date. The late plating period lasts for 20 to 25 days after the final plantingdate, depending on the state. “Acres planted within this window will receive 1% less insurance coverage per day,” he says. “Acres planted after the late planting period can still be insured at the prevented planting level which is 60% of the original guarantee.”He reminds that the late planted acres will be combined with any acres planted before the late planting window to determine your average guarantee if you utilize the enterprise unit discount.Since crop insurance is so farm-specific, Wasemiller says, any of these options could be correct for you. Be sure to ask for input from your crop insurance advisor. For 2019, Wasemiller suggests some over others. “My first choice is to take the full prevent plant claim,” he says. “My second choice is to continue to plant corn for up to a week after the final date.”Also, ask what your neighbors plan to do. “Don’t be that lone wolf in your area taking prevent plant. Adjusters and underwriters are getting a little more picky about quickly approving prevent plant acres.”If the majority of people in your area are getting their acres in, Wasemiller says, it may be best to have an adjustor come out to help determine if you land is eligible for a preventplant claim.